Howdy!
It's spooky season, and I'm sure there are plenty of lurkers like me looking for a good horror book right now. I just finished The Terror by Dan Simmons, and even though I've never posted a recommendation here before, I figured it was worth shouting this one out since I hadn't really heard of it and liked it a lot!
The elevator pitch: it's a character-focused, slow-burn/dread-y, supernatural historical fiction about a crew of British sailors in the 1840s who get stranded in the Arctic while searching for the Northwest Passage, and end up being hunted by a mysterious Big Bad.
Fair warning that it's a bit long at 700ish pages, but If that hooked you, scroll away and go get the book right now because I promise it delivers.
There are a few reasons this one really spoke to me. First, I had just read It by King (again, spooky season), and part of what keeps me coming back to King is how good he is at shifting perspectives and spending time fleshing out characters. Simmons does the same thing with his protagonists, and even though they're not perfect, by the end I really liked all of them in different ways because they all felt real.
Second, the sense of place in this book is insane. I live in the Northeast and it's only just starting to get cooler up here, but I still had to pull out my electric blanket. I literally felt colder while reading and very grateful for plentiful Vitamin C. He's so good at describing what daily life was like, the day-to-day routine, the weather, the hardships--it's incredibly well researched. The dread, slow-burn nature of it was also excellent. I was always on edge waiting for the monster to appear.
Finally, as a queer (male) POC, I did have some thoughts on how Simmons handles his women, queer, and POC characters. It's the 1840s, and the attitudes these white Englishmen have toward women, the Inuit, and "sodomites" don't seem unrealistic. I do think there's a bit of thinly disguised author fetish early on, when he spends a few extra words describing women's pubic hair. But the protagonists are nuanced and not universally likable, so it wasn't a dealbreaker for me that they held attitudes I disagreed with.
Anyone else read it and agree/disagree? Also, I would love some more recommendations if y'all have them about similar books. Huge nautical fiction fan here (Boneships Trilogy, Aubrey-Maturin series, Amina al-Sirfai, etc).
EDIT: OK some great recommendations in the comments (thanks to Thaliamims, ManufacturerDue815, GrapefruitOk1284, NarrowRoyal5074):
The Night That Finds Us All by John Hornor Jacobs is an eldritch horror on a luxury yacht.
The Route of Ice and Salt retells the voyage of the Demeter from Dracula, from the viewpoint of the ship's captain
At the Mountains of Madness by Lovecraft is also a polar horror story
The Abominable by Dan Simmons is a spiritual successor in a way, focused on a Mt. Everest expedition
Carrion Comfort by Dan Simmons looks like a horror book about a cabal of powerful psychics
Drood by Dan Simmons is about Charles Dicken’s search for the mysterious Edwin Drood from Dickens’ unfinished novel The Mystery of Edwin Drood