In 2014, Shahrukh Khan described his upcoming film Fan as something he wanted to do an intense, yet commercially viable film.
Looking back, that almost feels ironic, because the attempt to make the film more commercially viable is probably what hurt it.
The premise itself was fantastic. What happens when a superstar is confronted by a fan whose admiration crosses the line into obsession? It is one of cinema's most popular templates, and for good reason. The fan thinks he knows the star. The star doesn't even know the fan exists.
And Fan starts well.
Gaurav Chandna is interesting because he isn't an action hero. He's just a fan. He lives in Delhi, runs a small cybercafé, copies Aryan Khanna's mannerisms and knows everything about his films and career. Aryan isn't just his favourite actor. He has become a part of Gaurav's identity.
So when Gaurav goes to Mumbai to meet him and Aryan rejects him, he can't accept it. For Gaurav, this isn't just a superstar refusing to meet a fan. Aryan is rejecting a relationship that existed almost entirely inside Gaurav's head.
That's the most interesting part of the film.
But then the interval happens and the film starts becoming something else.
Instead of taking Gaurav's obsession further, the film turns him into an action/spy character. Suddenly he's travelling across countries, pulling off elaborate plans, escaping people and surviving things that feel completely out of character.
He basically becomes an Indian Ethan Hunt.
Gaurav should have become more dangerous psychologically, not physically. His obsession could have become more disturbing and unpredictable. He knows Aryan's habits, his public image and the way people around him behave. That could have made for a much better cat-and-mouse thriller.
Instead, the obsession becomes secondary to the chase.
And Aryan Khanna is another huge missed opportunity.
Shahrukh Khan playing both Gaurav and Aryan should have allowed the film to explore the difference between the celebrity a fan imagines and the actual person behind him. But we barely get to know Aryan.
Is he lonely? Is he tired of fame? Is he arrogant? Does he actually care about his fans? What does being worshipped by millions do to a person?
The film doesn't really explore any of this.
At times, it almost feels like Shahrukh Khan decided, "I'm Aryan Khanna." Instead of creating a fictional superstar who happens to be played by Shahrukh Khan, the film basically creates a fictional version of Shahrukh Khan.
The irony is that a film about a fan being obsessed with a superstar also becomes obsessed with its own superstar.
And this is also a bigger problem with mainstream Hindi cinema. We often change the movie at the interval instead of taking the same movie further.
The first half of Fan is a psychological story about obsession. The second half becomes an action chase. The instinct seems to be that the second half has to be bigger- more locations, more action, bigger set pieces.
But bigger isn't always better.
The second half should have taken Gaurav's obsession and pushed it further. Instead, it changes the entire nature of the conflict.
That's why Fan failed.