r/arduino • • 9d ago

The entire wire melted...

Idk whether it's because I used the wrong gnd (everything except the servo was on its gnd, the servo was on the Arduino gnd but the Arduino gnd was on the batteries) or because I hot glue the wires to the breadboard so they wouldn't fall out in 2 seconds

The second I plugged in the 12v for the l829n it started smoking and I unplugged everything.

I gutted everything, looks fine besides a selected few wires (has melted gunk in them) and I might need to use a different l829n.

34 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

26

u/negativ32 9d ago

Nice fuse.

10

u/tipppo Community Champion 9d ago

Exactly, and cheaper than a battery protection circuit!

5

u/NoBulletsLeft 8d ago

Electronics blow to protect fuses.

35

u/tipppo Community Champion 9d ago

Wires only melt like this when the battery + is connected to the battery -. This is not because you used the wrong GND, it's because your positive was connected to GND.

9

u/gm310509 400K , 500K , 600K , 640K , 750K 9d ago

Idk whether it's because I used the wrong gnd ...

This is a concern as it implies that you had a choice of GND.

Unless you have a specific reason to have separate GND connections, there should only be one GND and thus no reason to make a comment like that.

As others have said, the wires will only melt if too much current is going through them, and that will typically happen as a result of a short in your circuit.

Either way, you probably want to carefully review your circuit and compare it to your design. And if you didn't already create a schematic, do so now from your wiring as it may well (likely will) reveal the flaw.

10

u/Dickulture 9d ago

You're lucky the battery didn't go up. Li-ion batteries are known to catch on fire when shorted,

2

u/PresenceOld1754 9d ago

oh... I thought these ones were good...

10

u/tipppo Community Champion 9d ago

Li-ion batteries catch fire when they are overcharged or punctured. When they are shorted they deliver a lot of energy and can catch whatever causes the short on fire, not the battery.

3

u/PresenceOld1754 9d ago

Oh thank god, I was worried about the batteries exploding.

5

u/solitude042 9d ago edited 9d ago

Your 3.7v batteries are a reasonably energy-dense battery chemistry, but prone to fire if punctured or damaged. LiFePO4 is another li-ion chemistry with somewhat less energy density, but much safer. LiFePO4 also has a lower voltage (3.2v) but a much flatter discharge profile than li-ion.

(edited for correctness)

2

u/PresenceOld1754 9d ago

Sounds like the pros outweigh the cons, I'll look into lipos next time, tysm!

2

u/swisstraeng 9d ago

Ideally do your tests with alkaline batteries. Don't play with li-ion like that.

Also stay aware of the voltage. Alkalines are 1.5V, your li-ions here are rated for 3.7V. They can break most electrical items they fit in.

1

u/[deleted] 9d ago

In either case over discharge of the battery would result in an uncontrollable failure. The battery does say "protected" so it has a BMS module built into the battery, so it's fine. Also Li-ion is not a chemistry, it's a category. It is often used as a title and then you have to dig to figure out what the chemistry is. LiFePo4 is going to be the default for 18650s you buy today.

2

u/solitude042 9d ago edited 9d ago

Well, LiFePO4 is significantly more resistant to fire than other li-ion chemistries, but otherwise the corrections are appreciated! And I also misremembered the relative voltages - LiFePO4 has a lower voltage (~3.2) vs. the 3.7v of the OP's batteries. I'll edit accordingly. Thanks!

2

u/[deleted] 9d ago

Your right about the voltage, and I was mistaken - most 18650s seem to be INRs rather than the LiFePO4. I'm not sure they make 3.2v 18650 batteries, I've only ever seen them 3.7 (30Q and 35Es are what I use, mostly).

In a few years we'll have sodium ion batteries so that'll be exciting.

4

u/[deleted] 9d ago

You're right - the cell says "protected" which means it has a built in protection circuit. So a short circuit event would trigger something in there to interrupt the connection before the battery became over discharged.

2

u/Dry_Introduction_119 8d ago

they are, but you're lack of basic information about electricity. the wires are too small for this current

2

u/PresenceOld1754 8d ago

Gauge right? How thick the wire is? Yeah I wasn't thinking about that at all when I bought these.

I just assumed it was fine because why would they sell something that couldn't handle the electricity. I read the reviews and it did happen to another guy so I guess I'm not alone in this.

So if I wanted more power I'd need to replace these wires wire myself.

1

u/Dry_Introduction_119 8d ago edited 8d ago

let's assume that some Arduino and 2 dc motors will take the most current, so there's up to 6 amps in peak. those are li-ions so they actually will give this amount. I would suggest to use at least 20awg or even 18awg wire (0.8-1mm diameter) . actually pretty any wire with multiple threads in it. it won't melt moresoever won't even get warm

1

u/tipppo Community Champion 2d ago

Wires on these things would typically be 24AWG size. This is good for about 3 Amps continuous, so good for most applications. When your wires got toasted they were seeing 10s of Amps. It's difficult to change wires on these things. The wires are permanently crimped into place and the plastic melt if you try to solder wires to them. You could add a fuse to protect from the short circuit case.

2

u/agate_ 9d ago

Many such cases.

2

u/madsci 8d ago

You probably shorted it out, but that looks like not larger than 22 AWG wires. 18650 cells will easily put out enough juice to burn them out. You'll want to look at how much stall current all of your servos will draw to get your worst-case current, and the power wiring needs to be sized appropriately.

Regardless of what other grounds you've got set up, there is still only one ground wire going to the battery pack - and one positive wire. The total current of your project is carried by those two wires.

1

u/SuspiciousGarlic4798 9d ago

That shorted out or severelt overloaded for sure. 

Dont underestimate how much current can go through a shorted lithium. You can make the nickel strips glow if you short it.

Lucky thats all that happened. 

1

u/Rayzwave 8d ago

Always check the resistance between the power rails and any switched loads to make sure you have sensible resistance values and no short circuits. If you’re using batteries then remove them before making the resistance measurements.

1

u/Key-Answer4047 8d ago

There was to much electricity moving to fast through the wires and the electronic friction heated the wire. Large energy losses.

-1

u/DanongKruga 9d ago

something is either shorted or saw too high voltage