r/Mariners • ‏‏‎ ‎Cocoa Bomb Proton Therapist • 2d ago

Mariners Claim Michael Toglia

https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/10/mariners-claim-michael-toglia.html
81 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

In honor of Rick Rizzs' last season in the broadcast booth, please consider donating to Toys For Kids. A 501(c) non-profit organization founded by Rizzs and the late Dave Henderson, their goal is to provide hope via toys, school supplies, scholarships and more to homeless and disadvantaged children across Washington State.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

161

u/_Saint_Ajora_ 2d ago

His career numbers (1095 plate appearances)

  • WAR: -1.5
  • Batting average: .198
  • OBP: .275
  • SLG %: .384
  • strikeout rate: 35.1%

113

u/cruel_cousin #11 Edgar Martínez 2d ago

He sounds like a perfect fit

19

u/Narkolepse 2d ago

Don't forget a good portion of those numbers are from Coors.

26

u/SPEK2120 2d ago

Hear me out, if decent/good players we pick up often go opposite, what if bad players do the same? Let Jerry microwave!

3

u/monkeyboychuck Believe in Humpy 1d ago

Jerry can only burn toast.

12

u/Shadd518 2d ago

Maybe we do the thing where instead of someone who was good coming over and having numbers like this, we start with the bad numbers and see if they do the opposite?

11

u/_Elrond_Hubbard_ Too Roblessed to be stressed 2d ago

Playing in a hitter friendly environment like TMo Park should help his numbers right

3

u/KnuteViking 2d ago

Definitely a Seattle Mariners kind of guy.

2

u/twan_john 2d ago

You gotta think those numbers will decline at T-Mobile though right?

2

u/_Saint_Ajora_ 2d ago

yes, for no mariner hitter can defeat the vaunted "marine layer"

2

u/KILLALLEXTREMISTS 1d ago

Looks like we found our new DH, boys!

6

u/LegendRazgriz Fire Jerry Dipoto Now 2d ago

Sub 400 slugging having played in Coors his whole life, nice one dipshit surely this is an actual baseball player

14

u/JKthePolishGhost 2d ago

Dipoto claimed three stacked potted plants in a trench coat

1

u/WDoE #12 Josh Naylor 2d ago

He's absolutely perfect. How's his positional player pitching? Hopefully he can throw a 30mph lob somewhere in the same area code as home plate. We're so back.

69

u/atmospheric90 2d ago

Offseason off to a booming start i see.

Edit: career -1.5 WAR? Naylor's days are numbered

31

u/dankney 2d ago

He's here to replace Refsnyder, not Naylor

2

u/fennis ‏‏‎ ‎Might as well slighlty increase your budget doesnt cut it 2d ago

Id say he’s more of a potential back up for Naylor and a bench piece . Naylor went much of the year without a real backup.

2

u/_Saint_Ajora_ 2d ago

lets be real here, you dont need to be a defensive wizard to play first base, as that is a pretty common place to park a player that hits but can't field for beans

1

u/fennis ‏‏‎ ‎Might as well slighlty increase your budget doesnt cut it 2d ago

Here are the non Naylor first baseman

2

u/atmospheric90 2d ago

Chances aren't good, but never zero.

3

u/goms546 souvenir snack tray ferry boat connoisseur 2d ago

JERRY GOT HIS GUY

2

u/OrangeJuliusCaesr 2d ago

This amazing farm system that Jerry has created and he’s going after these guys

1

u/slicepaperwrists_ if I had to recommend proton therapy, I absolutely would 2d ago

a real "showing your ass" comment. this is a pure depth move. no one expects this guy to sniff the majors next year, but you still have to fill Tacoma with ballplayers

22

u/serpentear Tartan 365 | Cruiser 2d ago

The Goodwill bin is getting a little full, no?

We’ve got some Patrick Wisdoms in there, some Westin Wilson, a Leo Rivas.

6

u/_Saint_Ajora_ 2d ago

I wouldn't say goodwill bin.

I would equate this more to digging around the scrap wood bin in the shop and seeing if anyone threw in a piece of wood that could be turned into..... "something"

3

u/serpentear Tartan 365 | Cruiser 2d ago

36

u/florentinepogenFZ 2d ago

Grew up in Gig Harbor, Washington. Have always rooted for him to be successful. Friends with a few people I know. Career numbers have not been great though, which has been a bummer.

I personally doubt he figures it out, and I’m not sure why they made this move. However, I hope he does. Just wanted to provide a different perspective from all the (justifiable) confusion.

4

u/Im__TheGuy 2d ago

Sometimes coming home is all it takes. Plus, he’s got double dad strength now

4

u/seabear14 2d ago

Former Wenatchee AppleSox player too. Shoutout to the WCL.

1

u/NW_Ghost 2d ago

2026 Champs

5

u/OrangeJuliusCaesr 2d ago

This is pure Jerry move, he’s always trying to be a genius

13

u/Lanky-Budget-4661 2d ago

We like em cheap and hitting under 200

11

u/MarineLayerBad ‏‏‎ ‎Put Angie In The Booth 2d ago

C H I L L S

36

u/TheFracofFric ‏‏‎ ‎2026 All Star Cole Young 2d ago

Mariner

6

u/mahrinazz ‏‏‎ ‎Cocoa Bomb Proton Therapist 2d ago

mariner

5

u/dbalatero 2d ago

mariner.

6

u/Indigenous_Land ty Rick Rizzs 2d ago

Mariner

21

u/lelanddt Crafty Lefties Club 2d ago

They sure love collecting formerly good Rockies hitters

9

u/_Saint_Ajora_ 2d ago

i'm sorry, but when was he ever good?

12

u/AnnihilatedTyro ‎ RELEASE THE MOOSEN! 2d ago edited 2d ago

In 2024. Sort of. .767 OPS, 102 OPS+, 25 HR and 2.1 bWAR in only 458 plate appearances.

Just don't look at the rest of his career or remember that that was in Colorado.

8

u/slicepaperwrists_ if I had to recommend proton therapy, I absolutely would 2d ago

OPS+ is park adjusted so Colorado or not, it's not *terrible*

7

u/ovwAway ‏‏‎ It was 8-1 2d ago

Can we get him back to the 2024 version of himself? (Probably not)

8

u/_Saint_Ajora_ 2d ago

.218 average, 147 strikeouts in 458 plate appearances

be still my beating heart

🙄

2

u/SexiestPanda 2d ago

Jerry be like “we can replicate that!”

-2

u/SexiestPanda 2d ago

Jerry be like “we can replicate that!”

1

u/AtYourServais Seattle Mariners 2d ago

All that red was good for a wRC+ of 99.

8

u/griezm0ney 2d ago

Over/under 20 days before he is DFAd? This is the exact type of player teams try to slide through waivers to get moved to non-40 man depth. 

5

u/PendragonDaGreat Bring Back $5 Tallboys! 2d ago

That's what I was thinking. Just because you claim him doesn't mean you're going to use him immediately. The M's may have seen something they like and are trying to get him over to Tacoma to act as depth there while they coach him, and if that doesn't work then you just let him go entirely.

-1

u/ItsTBaggins ‏‏‎ ‎Julio makes me jard 2d ago

If he had options I’d see this as more of a viable depth move. As it stands I don’t really get this at all.

2

u/Former-Sea-8070 2d ago

They bought a cheap lottery ticket, there's nothing to "get." Maybe he turns into something, maybe he doesn't. If he doesn't, they just cut him loose with zero repercussions.

0

u/ItsTBaggins ‏‏‎ ‎Julio makes me jard 2d ago

If he clears waivers and elects free agency (likely) we could have tried to bring him in on a minor league deal and not given him a spot on the 40 man. As it stands he is on the 40 man and likely gets cut between now and Nov. and we then have to DFA him. I guess this lets us talk to him sooner and maybe we can get him looked at by our docs since he ended the season with a dislocated shoulder. We’ll now be on the hook for any rehab unless or until he signs a deal elsewhere regardless.

My point is we’re almost certainly going to give up our control of him and we’re not going to get to see if he turns it around first, it’s going to be a short turnaround.

1

u/slicepaperwrists_ if I had to recommend proton therapy, I absolutely would 2d ago

doesn't matter that he's out of options--he's never been outrighted before and doesn't have enough service time to turn down the assignment to Tacoma. unless some other team claims him on waivers we will be able to retain our control of him

1

u/ItsTBaggins ‏‏‎ ‎Julio makes me jard 2d ago

Waivers and shit are confusing. My initial take was ignoring the 3 years of service time thing, and so before I replied again I went and combed through the rules around this stuff again. I then went to see if he had been outrighted before. Like you I did not see that. However, last offseason, he was DFA’d and then able to elect free agency. That gives me the impression that he would be able to do so again.

1

u/slicepaperwrists_ if I had to recommend proton therapy, I absolutely would 2d ago

weird, right? I don't know the Rockies' logic there (who does?) but they'd have been able to outright him if they wanted him hanging around the org still. I believe that that dfa -> "elected free agency" progression is shorthand for him having simply been released

1

u/ItsTBaggins ‏‏‎ ‎Julio makes me jard 2d ago

I’m trying to think of and locate someone in a situation more similar to Toglia, but not having success. Robles was a different situation, he definitely could have elected free agency himself when the Nats DFA’d him. He shows as released though. Maybe Toglia’s entry was inaccurate, but I’d think if the Rockies just decided they didn’t want him it would say released similar to Robles.

1

u/slicepaperwrists_ if I had to recommend proton therapy, I absolutely would 2d ago

yeah I'm not sure how Robles' situation is different, though the transaction entry for him that succeeds that screenshot says "Seattle Mariners signed free agent CF Victor Robles." maybe it is purely nomenclature?

found some recent end-of-regular-season roster-management transactions (Lyon Richardson, Jose Urquidy, Joe Mantiply) and their pages all follow the DFA -> "elected free agency" form. strange

1

u/Former-Sea-8070 2d ago

There's literally no downside. They're going to try to get him in Tacoma. If that doesn't work, then so what? I'm so confused by the response in here.

1

u/AnnihilatedTyro ‎ RELEASE THE MOOSEN! 2d ago edited 2d ago

The only part of it I don't get is that he's likely to be DFA'd when we have to return all the 60-day IL guys to the 40-man for the offseason. Like, you don't need or even want a full 40-man when the season's done if you have a bunch of injured guys you want to hang onto.

We have SEVEN guys on the 60-day IL, and I think only 3 on expiring contracts.

It would make a lot more sense if this were a minor league deal or a NRI to spring training.

2

u/slicepaperwrists_ if I had to recommend proton therapy, I absolutely would 2d ago

as I said in a different reply: doesn't matter that he's out of options--he's never been outrighted before and doesn't have enough service time to turn down the assignment to Tacoma. unless some other team claims him on waivers we will be able to retain our control of him. outrighting takes him off the 40 man and simply dumps him into the minor league system

8

u/VorpalMatt 2d ago

Is this our new manager?

9

u/Bwana60 2d ago

Jerry Dipoto dumpster diving again.

4

u/3meraldBullet 2d ago

Let's see what he does in spring training and cut him early if he doesnt have it together. His bat does have some pop (at least at coors)

1

u/RobRefsnyder 2d ago

Coors HR factor isn’t super crazy

1

u/RobRefsnyder 2d ago

they just have a giant outfield

3

u/SeaPhile206 Angie Mentink 2d ago

We are so back.

4

u/nfiltr8r_89 Victor, lead us to VICTORy 2d ago

Chills

4

u/SexiestPanda 2d ago

Guy who had a decent season 3 years ago? Prototypical Jerry signing tbh

Jokes aside, he probably won’t make it to opening day, whenever that is

2

u/Bladley SELL THE TEAM 2d ago

Here we go mariner, here we go 👏 👏

2

u/primordialpouch12 2d ago

Gig Harbor native!

2

u/Repulsive-Party-5046 2d ago

I was just thinking we needed more strikeouts

2

u/CVBrownie ‏‏‎ ‎ 2d ago

Think yall are putting a little too much stock into an October 1st claim.

4

u/lanka2571 2d ago

scrolled too fast and thought this said Miguel Tejada

2

u/moe1984 2d ago

i guess he replaces nolan jones? almost literally the same circumstances, performance, and age. i would not expect him to be on the roster next season unless things have gone horribly wrong or horribly right.

1

u/Emotional-Cameraman 2d ago

he will fit right in.

1

u/tinydumper ‎‎‎‎‏‏‎ ‎ 2d ago

dude was awesome at UCLA

1

u/CTwist 2d ago

I liked his futures card in like mlb the show 22 or something so im sure hes gonna rake

1

u/Adventure-Style 2d ago

This is the missing piece

1

u/Ok_Nefariousness9401 1d ago

Dipoto special.

1

u/jjreddit1996 1d ago

This is very weird. He doesn’t have options, and there’s no chance he makes the 26 man.

0

u/Double_Swordfish_668 2d ago

Every move Jerry makes this offseason will be mocked and questioned. Even something that looks good on paper, which this certainly isn’t, will be ridiculed. He’s in a death spiral. Stanton did him no favors keeping him around.

-1

u/ihatereddit999976780 ‏‏‎ ‎54% child of Athena 2d ago

This might be the dumbest thing I’ve heard all day. And a fucking U-Haul crashed into a restaurant by my house this morning.

7

u/Former-Sea-8070 2d ago

No, this is the dumbest thing. You think they're building the team around him or something? They're going to try to get him in Tacoma. They might not even be able to do that without someone else claiming him first.

4

u/letskeepitcleanfolks ‏‏‎ ‎Swung on and belted 2d ago

I'm the biggest Jerry hater but the comments on stories like this are so predictably dumb. This is just some random roster move affecting the 50th spot on the depth chart that every team does dozens of times a year. It's not Jerry's fault someone decided to write an article that got posted to Reddit. No one is bragging about this as significant.

-8

u/seattlesportsguy ‏‏‎ ‎Just giving 54% of my effort here 2d ago

This is not a serious team

14

u/AnnihilatedTyro ‎ RELEASE THE MOOSEN! 2d ago

Oh, relax. The vast majority of all transactions, including this one, are just routine shuffling of minor leaguers, depth pieces, and roster spots.

8

u/drinkb0x 2d ago

Every single mlb franchise signs players like this.

1

u/Former-Sea-8070 2d ago

They're taking a long-shot on a guy the hope they can get back on track, at essentially zero cost. What's with the response?