I've been using "smart windows" in Firefox for about two weeks now and I don't understand the point of them at all. If anything I find it to be a very minor annoyance due to the new tab -> chat routing, but I am leaving it on in the hopes that it will improve.
This is what I want out of smart windows:
1) Automatic smart tab grouping.
I generally use my browser like this:
- open a bunch of youtube tabs with music, various interesting videos I want to watch, etc.
- do several "journeys" into topics of interest, for example recently I had several open tabs about historical lego sets, the movie Mars Express, stuff related to work, etc.
So I want tab grouping to be automatic, and customizable so I can give it rules to apply. I ALWAYS want youtube tabs treated a certain way (grouped together, minimized somewhere outside of the main tab bar, low memory usage / maybe even closed and just saved as a url). These same rules could apply to reddit tabs. This would be a useful and important function for firefox smart windows that could differentiate it from other browsers.
Firefox smart window SEEMS to have the ability to automatically do this. But in practice, whenever I open a new tab and start typing to search something, it just sends it to the local chat interface which SUCKS ASS. That feature, in my opinion should be ENTIRELY removed, or reworked so it's actually useful.
The core issue with the Ask feature is that the LLM they use is WAY too stupid to actually be of any use compared to the base ChatGPT, Claude, or even Gemini models which I use daily. So when it sends a new tab search to that LLM, I just get a useless, totally stupid response. I can post some screenshots of what I mean later. Honestly I don't want to use the Firefox Local LLM at all.
I discussed two features of smart windows:
- auto tab grouping which I like but needs to be improved
- firefox ask (the chatbot) which I hate and honestly want removed
I can't really even recall what other features smart windows have, I haven't seen anything else.
Do you agree with my thoughts here? How have you been using smart windows?